We are in the process of adding our new printable recipes cards to all recipes - stay tuned!

High Protein Reese’s Cup Ninja Creami

INGREDIENTS

 

1-2 oz more milk or half and half during “Re-Spin”

STEPS

Prep Instructions:

    1. Add and mix all of your ingredients together inside your Creami container and froth well to combine OR blend in your blender, then pour into creami container.

    2. Let your container rest uncovered for 5-10 minutes

    3. Cover and freeze overnight or until frozen. Usually takes the 24 hours 

Ninja Creami Instructions:

  1. Remove your frozen Creami container from the freezer and let it unthaw for 10 minutes or run the sides under some hot water for 1 minute.
  2. Place it into your Creami and hit the “Lite Ice Cream” button or “Ice Cream button” if you plan to use mix ins
  3. Add in 1-2 Ounces of Milk/Milk Substitute or half and half for extra creamy texture and hit the "Re-Spin" button. You may need to do this twice until desired consistency is achieved or not at all.
  4. (optional) If using mix in toppings, dig a hole in the center and put in a Reese’s cup, peanut butter chips, etc. Use the “Mix-In” button to blend in and enjoy! 
  5. For a “magic shell” topping I melt desired dark chocolate chips in the microwave in a glass bowl for 1 min and poured over. It’ll immediately harden to shell consistency. So good!


🍑 Nourishment Breakdown

Serves 1

Macros for whole pint without mix-ins: 
Calories: 340 | Fat: 4g | Carbs: 14g | Protein: 55g | Fiber: 3g


Did you make this recipe?
Tag @thepeachiespoon on Instagram and hashtag it #wellmadebythepeachiespoon
star
Back to recipes

5 comments

That was supposed to say
Is this doable WITHOUT a Ninja Creami?
———
thepeachiespoon replied:
No it’ll only work with a creami machine but use the search bar above for “Reese’s” and my smoothie recipe will pop up for you. It’s a blender option with similar taste

Kathy N

Is this do-able with a Ninja Creami?
———
thepeachiespoon replied:
Yes! It’s a ninja Creami recipe

Kathy N.

This was unbelievably wonderfull. I may have it for breakfast everyday!!!!
———
thepeachiespoon replied:
Ice cream for bfast?! Yesss🥳

Terri

I made this using the exact recipe and it is so delicious! I think the cottage cheese makes it so much creamier too! Thanks for sharing!

Monica K

Tastes EXACTLY like a Wendy’s Frosty!!

Lauren Miller

Leave a comment